Sunday, April 1, 2012

Nuclear Power

I received this email:

Hello,

I read your SunWeb blog. What are your thoughts on nuclear power, including fusion and fission power?


As for fusion, it has been ten years away - for decades. The best place for fusion is on the sun and the best way to use it is photosynthesis and passive solar. In other words, the sun provides energy through plant foods, animal foods, animal power, wood, some biomass, windmills (non electric) and well-designed structures.


There are four major reasons that I don’t support nuclear fission power now or in our future.


The first is simply, nuclear fission would not exist without fossil fuels. I mean the research, experimentation, testing, construction, maintenance, storage and decommissioning. It is an extension of the fossil fuel supply system. Both the economy and fossil fuel energy availability and cost will challenge present reactors. Without fossil fuels, nuclear power stations will not be built and will represent a serious danger over and above the danger the waste currently presents.


DNA India 2012-03-13: Eighty percent of the world's nuclear power plants are more than 20 years old, raising safety concerns, a draft UN report says a year after Japan's Fukushima disaster. Many operators have begun programmes, or expressed their intention, to run reactors beyond their planned design lifetimes, said the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) document which has not yet been made public. "There are growing expectations that older nuclear reactors should meet enhanced safety objectives, closer to that of... more »

http://article.wn.com/view/2012/03/13/Older_nuclear_plants_pose_safety_challenge_IAEA/

The danger of waste is the second reason. The thousands of years required to allow some of the waste to become non-toxic requires a stability in the world of which history shows no evidence.


Nuclear power is seen by nuclear utilities and congress as such a risk that:


The Price-Anderson Nuclear Industries Indemnity Act (commonly called the Price-Anderson Act) is a United States federal law, first passed in 1957 and since renewed several times, which governs liability-related issues for all non-military nuclear facilities constructed in the United States before 2026. The main purpose of the Act is to partially indemnify the nuclear industry against liability claims arising from nuclear incidents while still ensuring compensation coverage for the general public. The Act establishes a no fault insurance-type system in which the first approximately $12.6 billion (as of 2011) is industry-funded as described in the Act. Any claims above the $12.6 billion would be covered by a Congressional mandate to retroactively increa

se nuclear utility liability or would be covered by the federal government. At the time of the Act's passing, it was considered necessary as an incentive for the private production of nuclear power — this was because electric utilities viewed the available liability coverage (only $60 million) as inadequate.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price–Anderson_Nuclear_Industries_Indemnity_Act


Nuclear operators are not liable for the entire costs of their own nuclear accidents, and the financial burden for this risk is inappropriately transferred to taxpayers. Since corporations under Price- Anderson are only responsible for around two percent of the estimated cost of a serious accident, nuclear power corporations can largely ignore (from a financial perspective) the dangers that reactors impose on American communities.

www.citizen.org/documents/Price-Anderson-Factsheet.pdf


The story of the Price-Anderson Act

: how Congress made nuclear power financially viable in the U.S. by eliminating accountability for risk.

http://legalplanet.wordpress.com/2011/05/10/the-story-of-the-price-anderson-act-how-congress-made-nuclear-power-financially-viable-in-the-u-s-by-eliminating-accountability-for-risk/


Chernobyl and Fukushima speak for themselves as the third reason. They are the Black Swans (Nassim Nicholas Taleb) we can perhaps imagine, but not predict. One was direct human error; one was natural catastrophe with of course indirect human error. How many more? These are some of the unintended consequences of nuclear.




Each of the above are premium and primary reasons why I do not support nuclear power; however, there is a fourth that is truly my main reason. We humans, as a group and as most individuals, are not smart enough, wise enough, moral enough or mature enough to handle such power. All technology carries with it the unintended consequences mentioned above. We rush blindly into technological innovation because it will make life “easier”, it will immensely benefit some economically and we simply can not predict the complex effects.

Dillworth, Craig. 2010. Too Smart for Our Own Good. Cambridge Univ. London.

McCorriston, J. & Hole, F. 1991. “The Ecology of Seasonal Stress and Origins of Agriculture in the Near East.” American Anthropologist. V. 93. p. 46-49.


There is also the continued tendency of power technologies to be more centralized, demanding more draconian control measures and creating a dependency that makes humans beholden to the power distribution brokers. I find this an unhealthy trend.

Our human tendency of creating US-against-THEM thinking to strengthen our sense of identity and belonging adds a dangerous component to all potential technologies of such intrinsic power.

Eller, Jack. 2006. Violence and Culture. Thomson. Canada.

Eller, Jack David. 2010. Cruel Creed, Virtuous Violence. Prometheus. N.Y.

Avalos, Hector. 2005. Fighting Words. Prometheus. New York.

Berreby, David. 2005. Us and them : understanding your tribal mind. New York : Little, Brown and Co.

Cumpsty, John. 1991. Religion As Belonging. University Press of America. N.Y.

Docker, John. 2008. The Origins of Violence: Religion, History and Genocide. University of New South Wales.

Kiernan, Ben. 2007. Blood and Soil: A World History of Genocide and Extermination from Sparta to Darfur. Yale Univ. New Haven.

Rozenblit, Bruce. 2008. Us against them : how tribalism affects the way we think. Kansas City, MO : Transcendent Publications.

Volkan, Vamik. 2004. Blind Trust. Pitchstone. Virginia.

Wellman, James. 2007. Belief and Bloodshed. Rowman and Little. N.Y.

Wentz, Richard. 1993. Why People Do Bad Things in the Name of Religion. Mercer University Press. Georgia.


It is clear to me sustainability is a living process and a process of living. Nuclear does not fit this process.

Tuesday, March 6, 2012

AUTOBIOGRAPHY


I was born in Deland, Florida, on April 7, 1943.  I grew up in Hialeah, Florida.  During the fourth grade I was in a combined fourth and fifth grade class.  I participated in both so was advanced directly to the sixth grade.  At the age of eight I started a lawn mowing business that was year round in Florida.  By the time I graduated from Miami Jackson High School I had worked at various jobs including movie usher, at a fast food drive-in and summers loading trucks in a warehouse.   Along with keeping up with my studies and the working, at the age of 13 I made Eagle Scout, one of only four in the United States to accomplish this at that age.

I attended the University of Florida to study psychology but after a semester and a half I became restless, quit school and roamed around the south until 1961 when I joined the Air Force.  After having high entrance testing results and further testing I was placed in intelligence and sent to Indiana University to study Russian.  Not being a good match for the work in intelligence, I was transferred to photography.  

I spent the rest of my military career at McCord AFB in Tacoma, Washington.  Once, they removed the double doors from a Gooney Bird the C-47, put ropes across, roped me to it and flew at a slant while I took pictures of an airfield.  Prior to being discharged, I was in charge of the photo lab and had 11 people under him, all of whom outranked him.  During his time in the service, I had night jobs and also picked up college courses at the University of Puget Sound.

After the Air Force, I had a desire to learn about either marine biology or anthropology, interests gained from reading during the service.  I went back to Miami, went to night school and worked full theme at the University of Miami Marine Lab on Key Biscayne.  Deciding on anthropology (the scientific study of the origin and of the physical, social and cultural development and behavior of humans) I attended Florida State University and graduated in 1968.  To pay my way, I had three jobs along with the GI Bill and some scholarships.  I worked at the university pool on the weekends, at the anthropology department and as night auditor at the Holiday Inn.

After getting my degree, I went back to Miami and found a job with a linguist at the University of Miami. The linguist had done communication work with porpoises along side Lilly, who wrote Mind of the Dolphin and THE Human Biocomputer.  My boss and I recorded sounds from porpoises and killer whales at the Miami Seaquarium.   I had the opportunity to swim with seals and wild porpoises.  After a while this grant ran out. I still had an interest in anthropology especially in the field of religion and medicine.  I went to work with Julia Morton (an internationally famous botanist) at the Morton Collectania on the University of Miami campus.

In 1968 while fishing in Biscayne Bay, I was looking at the Miami skyline, thinking about how civilization took away too much of the humanity of too many and stuffed us into areas with too many of our own kind and not enough connection to the natural world.  I had a strong realization that civilization, as we know it today cannot endure.  It was at that time in 1968 that I decided to “go back to the land”.  In this quest, I traveled to Mexico (six months), and then to Oregon were I purchased a house and lived for two and a half years.  I also visited Hawaii for three months where people I knew from the porpoise research lived.  I sold the Oregon house and went looking for land, finally ending up in Central Minnesota in 1973.


In 1972, Limits to Growth came out.  So besides not being healthy for humans psychologically, sociologically or spiritually, I learned we are creating an unsustainable, environmentally devastating and devastated world.
 Further reading reinforced my knowledge from an ecological and environmental perspective -  Energy for Survival by Wilson Clark, Energy Basis for Man and Nature by Howard T. Odum and Elisabeth C. Odum, The Fires of Culture by Carol E Steinhart.

In Central Minnesota, I purchased 93 acres outside of Long Prairie with money from the sale of the Oregon house.  I built a home having never done construction and my first winter dumped one of the largest snowstorms in Minnesota history.   Not being completely finished, it rarely got above 50 degrees in the home all winter.  I remembers my third winter in my home, this Florida boy who didn’t see snow until I was eighteen, when I ran out of wood in March and had to lasso dead branches out of trees to stay warm and cook.  In my home, I used kerosene lamps and cooked on a 1935 copper-clad wood cook stove that I got for $25.  I heated with a wood heater I helped to build and pumped my water up to a retaining tank for gravity feed around the home.

During my first year in my new home, I made a deal with a neighbor farmer that I would work for him if the farmer would feed me one meal a day. I cleaned calf barns, helped milk, tore down a tractor, and threw silage down.   All of this work taught me a deep respect for our old time farmers

I purposely built without electricity and lived that way the first ten years because I do not believe nuclear waste should be our legacy to the future. In 1974, I went to work for the Tri County Community Action Program out of Little Falls, Minnesota, where I wrote the first proposal and ran the first Low Income Weatherization Program in Minnesota.  In this proposal I put in a small part to build window box solar collectors.  From this solar connection, I built a business called Creative Alternatives where I designed, tested, manufactured, and installed solar panels.  I had ten dealers around the state.  I built a garage on my land near the road where I brought in electricity to build the solar hot air panels. 

THE 70s was a busy decade for me.  Besides running my solar business, I was elected chairperson of the Solar Resource Advisory Panel for three years, which advised the state and organized solar activities.  I also sat on the Mid-America Solar Energy Complex, a federal project with headquarters in the Twin Cities.  Also during this time I went back to school to get a degree in psychology from St. Cloud University.  I did all my work at home using kerosene lamps.

In 1983, I erected a wind generator built in 1935 that I found for $300. I also put up some solar panels.  I spent more time forty feet in the air trying to get the generator working then I did getting electricity from it.  During the next years I went through three generators and bought more panels.  I had a small inverter to run my computer and other appliances like a vacuum cleaner.  I lived on approximately 1-kilowatt hour a day. Most homes use 20kWh a day or more. 

In 1983, I decided to leave the solar business and use my psychology degree.  In 1985, I received my license.  I sectioned off a part of the garage and built an office.  Many of my clients were women who had experienced childhood abuse.  I received referrals from Todd County Social Services and ultimately my business was word of mouth.  During this time I was asked to work under contract with a program at the St. Francis Center in Little Falls, Minnesota.  Women of all Catholic orders came in from all over the world for nine months of spiritual and psychological growth and development.  I facilitated three groups of approximately ten women in each group once a week.  I also worked with the director on more difficult cases.   All the staff were Sisters except for me nor was I Catholic.   I feel this was one of the most important and growthful experiences of my life.   The women were absolutely amazing.

In 2003, I was diagnosed with severe lung cancer and given a few weeks to live.  While receiving extremely harsh radiation treatment and chemotherapy for seven weeks, I still continued to split wood because it was March and I needed it for cooking and heating.  My neighbors did come over and help me out considerably.   The Sisters drove me to treatment every day for the seven weeks even though by this time I no longer worked at the program.

During treatment, I asked to see a regular picture of his CT Scan.  I had them put this on a CD and created a picture using my computer.  From this I contacted the Coburn Cancer Center Foundation hoping to make T shirts for kids to wear.   This led me to the drug prevention program at the St. Cloud Hospital.  For the next two years, while still recovering from treatment I went around the state talking to over 2000 youngsters about not smoking.  I also by myself purchased billboard signs showing a picture of my cancer tumor and a plea “Do Not Smoke.”   Several of the students at schools where I spoke held bake sales and with the help of the Lions Club put up additional billboards. The American Lung Association out of Duluth also paid for a billboard when I went to Duluth to speak to classes.  The last of these could be seen on Highway 200 going east from the casino.  It was take down after five years (when I only paid for one.)

My neighbor went with me to my student presentations and video taped it.  The neighbor then created a DVD of the presentation.   This DVD is in various countries of the world including the following: Brazil, South Africa, England, Switzerland, Norway, Japan, Australia and around the United States.  Having survived cancer and its treatment, I am in remission and doing fabulously.

Just prior to his cancer, I reduced my psychological practice to two days a week because of the toll that hearing so much pain takes on a person.   I began developing websites and doing graphics.  I joined the board of Central Minnesota Sustainable Farming Association.   Through them I put on two conferences in 2000 and 2001 on Alternative Energy and Global Warming respectively.

I sold my place near Long Prairie in 2004 and moved with my partner, Kathryn Wagner, to live on Wabedo Lake where we have a 3kWh solar electric grid-thee system that gives electricity to the home.  When there is extra juice it feeds the electricity back into the power line.   We also have a garden and we recently built a greenhouse at the lake home.  

We are bought a piece of land near us. We have developed an orchard and a truck garden.  We put in fencing and reconditioned the small home there.  A well was put in that uses a pumpjack like in the old time so that it can ultimately be powered by solar panels and a 1/2 horsepower 12 volt DC motor or a bicycle with a pulley to the pumpjack.   We put in irrigation and worked up an area for blueberries where we now have 400 plants to be a pick-your-own enterprise.  We are also developing a specialty potato business.

Although I used solar and wind, I believe these are at best transitional technologies.  We will ultimately live at a much simpler, less energy intensive per capita level.  Solar and wind require equipment that requires mining, refining, manufacturing and transporting.  All of these processes rely on fossil fuels.   This actually makes these sources of energy not renewable.   A horse is renewable, an oak tree is renewable.  Ultimately, any source of energy we use must be able to renew itself.  I believe that our children and certainly their children will live not in Star Trek, but far simpler.

I refer to King Hubbard, a petroleum geologist for Shell Oil who wrote a paper in 1956 predicting that the ability of the US to produce oil would peak in 1970 and decline there after.  Except for Prudoe Bay and the Gulf of Mexico, which only added two additional years, the ability of the U.S. to produce oil has been on the decline.  Petroleum geologists have continued this work looking at world oil peaking.   All the data coming from multiple researches indicates easily accessible petroleum peaked in 2005 and petroleum from many sources peaked in 2008.  Now we are “scrapping the bottom of the barrel” with fracking, tar sands and deep ocean drilling to get the dregs that are expensive not only energy and financial costs but also environmental devastation. I say beware of snake oil and fantastic claims that do not hold up under the scrutiny of geology and physics. The way we live today is a global web so to maintain this lifestyle any solutions we consider must be global.

I feel my life has been a wonderful adventure including the experience of the cancer and the four stents they put into his arteries the year after cancer treatment.  I wished often that I could share the joy of being alive with the young people I spoke with about not smoking.  I am concerned that, like I denied the seriousness of smoking, people are ignoring, denying or finding other psychological defenses to avoid accepting the convergence of so many issues that will change the way we live. 

In November of 2015, I went into the hospital for an operation on my lungs.  The first one didn't take and they had to repeat within a week.  I laid on my back for the month of November with two huge tubes coming out of my back.  Then I was totally bed ridden for December and January.  Finally I am coming around to much more activity.  I am on oxygen 24/7 but have gotten the gardens rototilled and lots of other work done.  This is the second time I have had to fight back.  Whew.


Thursday, February 23, 2012

Get A Job

We are trapped. A friend of mine, very bright, knows engines backwards and forwards has gone to the fracking fields in North Dakota to work. He is around 30, has a family and was working a seasonal job. Now he is raking in the money. He told me one day they didn’t have anything for him, he sat in his truck all day and earned a lot of money.

He needs a job. The way we live, we need fossil fuel energy. If we are polluting the water, polluting the air, upsetting the seismic situation , so be it. He needs a job and the way we live, we need fossil fuel energy. If he doesn’t do this work, there will be a flood of job loss repercussions locally and across the nation.

For a powerful, well-documented explanation with charts of chemicals as well as environmental and health effects of fracking see: http://www.earthworksaction.org/issues/detail/hydraulic_fracturing_101

On top of being a dangerous assault on the ground water, water use, air quality and human health, we are picking at crumbs. See:

http://www.smartplanet.com/blog/energy-futurist/energy-independence-or-impending-oil-shocks/375

Destruction of land and contamination of water and air for jobs, oil and of course

money is taking place at the tar sands in Alberta, Canada.

Oil Sands Could ‘Delay’ Peak Oil - Candice Beaumont

http://www.hardassetsinvestor.com/features-and-interviews/1/2419-candice-beaumont-oil-sands-could-delay-peak-oil.html

** from a portion of the interview****

Ludwig: Where else are oil sands located besides Canada?

Beaumont: There are some oil sands in the United States as well. In Utah there are some oil sands, and in West Texas. But it's harder to produce in the U.S., because it's still environmentally very difficult.

In Canada, it's in very remote places, it's 40 below zero, nobody is

going to that neighborhood. In the U.S., in West Texas, people live

where the oil reserves are and so you couldn't have the type of

environmental impact that they are doing in Canada, where they are

basically destroying the environment. If a bird flies over a river near

the oil sands, the bird dies just from flying over the river. It's that

toxic. They are just dumping all the waste into the waterways. If you

did that in the U.S. you would be in jail.

Ludwig: Is that going to be an issue over the long term?

Beaumont: It's an issue. But because it's in remote areas and not

inhabited, they aren't worrying about the pollution, because nobody

lives in that area. So, they can do it.

We do live there, it is the earth.


A friend of my works at one of the big ski resorts in Colorado. Every year, but I guess especially this year, they are making snow. We do the same here in Minnesota. If they didn’t make snow, which to me is the height of arrogance and waste of energy and misuse of water, the job losses would be huge. Not just at the ski resort, but job losses would resound throughout the community and down the mountain.


In my essay on saving energy (http://sunweber.blogspot.com/2011/11/saving-energy.html), I show pictures of a football stadium filled with people and a parking lot filled with cars. This is a tremendous use of energy during the football season and all other spectator sports – soccer, basketball, baseball, etc. – throughout the world, throughout the year. The loss of jobs here would affect whole towns, whole states, whole countries.

We will do anything and everything to maintain our present personal level of energy use and the comfort it affords us. We will do anything and everything to the earth, to other people and even to ourselves to continue on this path. And if we don’t have the energy level we see others have, we will do anything and everything to the earth, to other people and even to ourselves to attain that level. The proof of this assertion is simple; we are doing it.

From: The Curmudgeon Report

http://sunweber.blogspot.com/2011/02/curmudgeon-report.html


As the U.S. of A. empire winds down, our military men and women will be coming home. Many of these men and women have been trained in high tech, energy intensive fields and in war. Where will these thousands of people work? What kind of job?


Manufacturers, assemblers, installers, maintenance people and bureaucrats inspecting and providing grants for solar and wind devices, as I have written in multiple places, are extensions of the fossil fuel world will be idle when fossil fuels are scarcely available.

See: http://sunweber.blogspot.com/2011/01/energy-in-real-world.html

http://sunweber.blogspot.com/2011/12/machines-making-machines-making.html


A dear friend is an interior designer. Enough said.


These careers/jobs have been valuable and contributing in the world of cheap, easily accessible fossil fuels and with the ongoing paradigm of continual growth. The men and women have been hard working people enmeshed in the ongoing vision of the their world. They are not to be denigrated for this past; their jobs are simply extraneous and not supportable in the coming world.


We are trapped in needing to squeeze out every molecule of fossil fuel energy we can. It is threatening air, ground water, rivers, oceans, seismic activity, soil, and human health, but we have no choice.


John Michael Greer: The Myth of the Machine

The strategy discussed in last week’s post—that of walking away from energy-intensive lifestyles before the waning of the age of abundant energy brings them grinding to a halt—is a viable response to the crisis of our age, but it’s also a great way to poke a stick at some of the most deeply entrenched of the modern world’s dysfunctional habits of thinking. Suggest it in public, for example, and you’ll very quickly learn why all that talk about saving the planet has turned out to be empty air: everyone’s quite willing to watch someone else make sacrifices for the good of the biosphere, but ask them to make sacrifices themselves and you’ll see just how far their love of the planet extends.

http://thearchdruidreport.blogspot.com/2012/01/myth-of-machine.html

WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 25, 2012


“Inevitably, the luxury of yesterday tended to become the treat of today and the necessity of tomorrow.”

Smith, Richard. 2009. Premodern Trade in World History. Rutledge. N.Y. pg. 91

Easy and cheap

“There is within every human the perpetual pull of opposites. Fear taunts courage; willpower struggles with appetite; order with disorder. Caution tugs at curiosity as impulse teases aversion. For all the stimulation of the new, there remains the powerful comfort and security of the known. We are, like Dr. Dolittle’s famous Pushme-Pullyou, conflicted creatures. Individuality is defined by these differences, by where the balance is struck.

But one impulse in particular seems to have weak competition or none at all. The appeal of ease, or the less-taxing option, is unquestioned. Only the obstinate, the perverse, the eccentric, or the mad, the conventional wisdom toes, intentionally choose the more difficult over the easier method of reaching a goal. The hatchet or the ax over the chain saw? “I like the feel of the ax in my hand, the resistance, the thud of impact. I like to feel I am linked to what I am doing. I like the quiet in the forest, the smell of rosin, even the living shudder of the tree as the x bites, “ says the old woodsman. The logger smiles, pulls the starter on his chain saw, and has seven trees down in the time the woodsman spends on one. And the logger’s boss brings in the feller-buncher, the giant machine that grasps each tree in a steel embrace, then cuts it and stacks it with its downed companions as if it were kindling; and logger smiles no more as the new machine does the work of seven chain-saw-bearing men and he finds himself reading want ads. Seldom, however, is the original impulse to make things easier questioned.

The religious have always known that ease is a dangerous road to travel. One reason for caution is that it’s sometimes hard to tell who the real beneficiary is. Or whether something is really as easy as it first seems. Or whether ease costs more than it appears to. Or whether something is being lost in the transition that hasn’t been mentioned, or foreseen, or accounted for. Machines, in the time of Carlyle, Dickens, and Ruskin, were making production easier. The matter of “at what cost” had just begun to be considered, and then only by a very few.

Close on the heels of ease is cheap, and the combination, especially in goods, is virtually irresistible. Low cost and convenience: the machine made it possible.

Pg. 79-80 Fox, Nicols. 2002. Against the Machine. Island Press. London.

Also found in my essay: http://sunweber.blogspot.com/2011/10/to-make-light-bulb.html


My partner is a teacher of special education. Her teaching may continue but I don’t see special education being funded down the line in a diminishing economy. She would like to retire in 2015. We will see. My primary job before I retired because of my lung cancer was as a psychologist in private practice. I see this as a tradable skill for money and goods. I might need a rattle and a drum if we turn tribal. :-)


We are presently developing an orchard/garden that will be workable without electricity or fossil fuels if need be. We have a large below grade root cellar. This spring we are building a greenhouse that will function for at least ten months if not year round (we will have to see). We fenced our orchard and fields with good, high material that should last decades. At our age, we will need some young muscle for help, which I believe will be an easy find.


What work do you do?


Who will make the shoes, weave the cloth, spin the yarn, work the forge, grow the food?

Monday, February 20, 2012

Over and over

These three books give good evidence of how a trading economy for net profit has probably existed since the beginning of human existence. Given any animals propensity to use as many and all the resources in its environment to survive and reproduce humankind is tough on the environment and eventually itself.

Smith, Richard. 2009. Premodern Trade in World History. Rutledge. N.Y.

Reinhart, Carmen and Rogoff, Kenneth. 2009. This Time is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly. Princeton U. Princeton.

Chew, Sing. 2007. The Recurring Dark Ages. AltiMira. N.Y.

Together they essentially say some form of trading has been around for thousands of years in one form or another. After person to person or group to group of the Paleolithic, trading evolved. One initial form was with governments including the religious hierarchy financing trade between other powers. The aim was primarily to get goods not available in their area as well as to develop allies but some profit was extracted. This moved into a more entrepreneurial phase with top families financing trade expeditions on land and water for profit. All of this took place thousands of years ago.

For thousands of years there has been a convergence of misuse of people by the wealthy, environmental degradation vis a vis the particular resources valued at the time and natural happenings such as volcanic eruptions, climate change, floods that brings about periodic crashes (dark ages) that last at least decades if not centuries. It has generated crashes periodically across millenniums that mirror this latest one.

<<<<<<<<<<<<

Trade in the past:

Two non-perishable commodities that serve as good examples of how long-distance trade worked in the Neolithic and Bronze Ages are obsidian and amber. Obsidian is volcanic glass formed by the cooling of viscid lava. . . .

In the prehistoric world, nothing made a sharper edge for knives, daggers, scapers, razors, sickles, and projectile points for spears, harpoons, and arrowheads than obsidian. . . . By Neolithic standards, it was a high-value item. . . .

. . . a good deal of flux is apparent in the obsidian trade. Over a period of time, a particular site can go from having 90 percent of its stone tools in obsidian to practically nothing and later back up to 90 percent. No doubt the trade was widespread, and today obsidian tools are found scattered across southwest Asia and parts of Europe hundreds of miles from their source.

Extracted from – Smith, Richard. 2009. Premodern Trade in World History. Rutledge. N.Y. pgs 19-20

“Inevitably, the luxury of yesterday tended to become the treat of today and the necessity of tomorrow.” Smith, Richard. 2009. Premodern Trade in World History. Rutledge. N.Y. pgs91

Another example of distant trade in the distant past:

Lapis laxuli occurs naturally in very few places worldwide. The closest to the ancient centers of civilization was in Badakhatan in the snowy mountains of northeastern Afghanistan 1,500 miles as the crow flies from Mesopotamia and twice that far over the circuitous routes trades actually traveled. . . .

Lapis first appeared in northern Mesopotamia in the form of beads at the end of the fifth millennium bce although it did not become abundant until the middle of the fourth.

Smith, Richard. 2009. Premodern Trade in World History. Rutledge. N.Y. pg. 37

<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<

Economic folly

Varieties of crises:

1. Inflation crises - An annual inflation rate of 20 percent of higher

2. Currency Crashes – An annual depreciation versus the relevant anchor currency of 15 percent or more.

3. Currency Debasement –

A. A reduction in the metallic content of coins in circulation of 5 percent or more.

B. A currency reform whereby a new currency replaces a much-depreciated earlier currency in circulation.

4. The bursting of Asset Price Bubbles (equity or real estate)

5. Banking crises –

A. Bank runs that lead to the closure, merging, or takeover by the public sector of one or more financial institutions.

B. The closure, merging, takeover, or large-scale governemtnt assistance of an important financial institutions (or group of institutions) that marks the start of a string of similar outcomes for other financial institiutions.

6. External debt crises – outright default on a government’s external debt obligations.

7. Domestic debt crises – the freezing of bank deposits and/or forcible conversions of such deposits from dollars to local currency.

Reinhart, Carmen and Rogoff, Kenneth. 2009. This Time is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly. Princeton U. Princeton. pg. 4-11

“Broadly speaking, financial crises are protracted affairs. More often than not, the aftermath of severe financial crises share three characteristics:

1. Asset market collapses are deep and prolonged. Declines in real housing prices average 35 percent stretched out over six years, whereas equity price collapses average 56 percent over a downturn of about three and a half years.

2. The aftermath of banking crises is associated with profound declines in output and employment. The unemployment rate rises an average of 7 percentage points during the down phase of the cycle, which lasts on average more than four years. Output falls (from peak to trough) more than 9 percent on average, although the duration of the downturn, averaging roughly two years, is considerably shorter than that of unemployment.

3 . . . the value of government debt tends to explode . . . “

Reinhart, Carmen and Rogoff, Kenneth. 2009. This Time is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly. Princeton U. Princeton. Pg. 224

“Broadly speaking, financial crises are protracted affairs. More often than not, the aftermath of severe financial crises share three characteristics:

1. Asset market collapses are deep and prolonged. Declines in real housing prices average 35 percent stretched out over six years, whereas equity price collapses average 56 percent over a downturn of about three and a half years.

2. The aftermath of banking crises is associated with profound declines in output and employment. The unemployment rate rises an average of 7 percentage points during the down phase of the cycle, which lasts on average more than four years. Output falls (from peak to trough) more than 9 percent on average, although the duration of the downturn, averaging roughly two years, is considerably shorter than that of unemployment.

3 . . . the value of government debt tends to explode . . . “

Reinhart, Carmen and Rogoff, Kenneth. 2009. This Time is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly. Princeton U. Princeton. Pg. 224

Letter to Dr. Carmen Reinhart and Dr. Kenneth Rogoff, sent 2/1/2012

I have enjoyed your book, This Time is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly, in giving me an outline of historical “financial folly” and how it pertains to the present. I would ask if this time is actually different because of the convergence of population (underwritten these last 200 years by fossil fuels) overshoot, peaking of easily accessible, relatively low cost petroleum, tremendous environmental degradation that is accelerating in attempt to maintain lifestyle via fracking, tar sands, assault of the arctic, deep water drilling, mountain top removal, depletion of food fish stocks, depletion of potable water and aquifers, topsoil depletion and other non-fuel mineral depletion or scarcity.

Sing Chew in his book The Recurring Dark Ages proposes that for multiple millennium there have been a convergence of oppression of people by the wealthy, environmental degradation vis a vis the particular resources valued at the time and natural happenings such as volcanic eruptions, climate change, floods that brings about periodic crashes (dark ages) that last at least decades if not centuries. I believe we are on the edge if not in the midst of one of these convergences. This time it is global as is the concerns I outlined in the above paragraph.

“Unlike past Dark Ages, the options today are limited in terms of the various paths for system recovery. In the previous Dark Age period, the world system was not as globalized and encompassing, and system could expand in terms of the search for natural resources and labor, thereby enabling previously degraded and exploited areas to recover. At this stage of the globalization process, planet Earth is fully encompassed, and thus if ecological collapse (Dark Age) occurs there are few replacement areas for system expansion. Besides this, the level of connectivity of the world system in terms of production and reproduction processes means that the collapse will be felt globally, unlike previous Dark Ages in which not all the peripheral areas were impacted by the collapse.

Chew, Sing. 2007. The Recurring Dark Ages. AltiMira. N.Y. pg. 181

http://sunweber.blogspot.com/2011/05/we-are-here.html

http://sunweber.blogspot.com/2011/05/new-middle-ages.html

and

http://www.blottr.com/world/breaking-news/peak-oil-crisis-no-one-talking-about

http://ourfiniteworld.com/2012/02/01/the-most-important-resource-for-our-future-inexpensive-oil/#more-14593

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/03605442/37/1

Scroll down to: “Oil supply limits and the continuing financial crisis”